
2 June 2025
Human intelligence, the end of SEO and why semicolons matter
During May I’ve been in defence of things that might be dying out. Reading books. Semicolons. And copyright for creatives.
Things I learnt this month
I came across some new digital marketing acronyms this month.
GEO stands for generative engine optimisation. This is like search engine optimisation (SEO) but for AI. The aim is to get your content cited in AI-generated responses from ChatGPT, Google’s AI overviews and similar services.
The term was coined in 2023 but I’ve only just started seeing people using it: some have noticed their Google Analytics reports showing that ChatGPT is now driving traffic to their website. It is, apparently, the future of SEO.
SXO (search experience optimisation), meanwhile, is a cross between SEO and UX (user experience). The focus here is not just on getting a high place in search engine rankings, but giving users a valuable “journey” once they reach your website (or other digital channel).
(This is not a new concept, by the way; it’s why we look at “bounce rates” as well as traffic when analysing how well a website is doing in search.) It is, apparently, the new SEO – according to multiple LinkedIn articles. But here’s a more useful and sober overview.
In praise of semicolons
It was announced this month that semicolons are dying out. Or, at least, they are appearing less frequently in recently published books. Cue lots of headline writers gleefully using semicolons to report on this.
Financial Times: “Semicolons bring the drama; that’s why I love them”
The Conversation: “Semicolons are becoming increasingly rare; their disappearance should be resisted”
The Spectator: “The semicolon had its moment; that moment is over”
The Independent: “Semicolons: Our best punctuation mark is dying out; people need to learn how to use it”
Even the Daily Mail got in on the act, with: “Experts reveal semicolons are at risk of dying out; do YOU know how to use the once-popular punctuation mark?”
Subeditors at the Guardian and Telegraph missed their chance, with “Marked decline in semicolons in English books, study suggests” and “Why the semicolon could die out”.
Meanwhile, HuffPost UK went into clickbait mode with: “Using This Punctuation Mark May Reveal Your Age, Experts Say.”
If you’re a semicolon fan, as I am, check out Cecelia Watson’s book Semicolon, which I reviewed on my blog when it came out.

In praise of reading
I was delighted to find out that the National Centre for Writing was organising an international celebration of reading on 24th May, and even more delighted to discover they were calling it Page Against The Machine.
“Join us in the rebellious act of reading!” they invited us via their Facebook page. I always read every day anyway, but I did like the notion of it being rebellious. And maybe it is. That same week, I was sitting in the dentist’s waiting room reading, when someone walked past and said “Good book?” In a tone that sounded as if I was doing something weird.
Should have gone to… a better copywriter
Marketing people and copywriters will be familiar with the concept of a brand having a “tone of voice”. People spend a lot of money trying to define what theirs should be. And sometimes the money is not well spent.
After ordering a new pair of glasses from Specsavers, I received two very excitable emails.
The first had the subject line “Great to see you yesterday, Penny” and was headed with a large “thank you” banner covered in animated hearts. The text read: “Hi Penny, We’re thrilled that you’ve chosen Specsavers for your new glasses… Bet you can’t wait. And we’ll be right there to share the occasion with you.”
The follow-up was headed “A day to celebrate” and read: “Hi Penny, Tomorrow will be a great day. That’s because your new glasses will be ready for you to collect from Specsavers Didcot. If you’re excited at the thought, we don’t blame you. We are too.”
To which the obvious answer is: No, you’re not.
This kind of language doesn’t give me warm feelings towards Specsavers. It’s inauthentic and actually a bit creepy.
Buying glasses is not exciting: it’s an expensive necessity. I use Specsavers because they are slightly less expensive than other opticians, not because they are my friend. I don’t have any brand loyalty, and no amount of weird copywriting is going to create it.

Your monthly mention of AI
It’s been another month of thinking about AI. I wish I didn’t have to, because there are many more interesting things to think about. But I don’t think it’s an exaggeration to say we are in the middle of a cultural crisis.
It’s not all bad; in fact I hear the phrase “AI for good” a lot. I’ve just been editing a paper on the potential for AI in the development sector and came across a report that looks at AI’s potential to achieve the Sustainable Development Goals.
On the other hand, generative AI continues to churn out “slop”, and is already taking jobs, and the copyright issue won’t go away.
So we need to distinguish between generative AI (a nightmare) and other applications (potentially positive). Because those of us in the creative industries who are part of the backlash are not Luddites – but we do want our culture to survive, and our politics not to be poisoned by fake information.
As researcher Angus Main commented on a Bluesky thread: “We need better language about AI. We can’t use the same term for the process that detects cancer as the process that make your photo look like a Ghibli. If we restrict the program that’s designed to specifically steal IP it doesn’t mean all the other applications cease to exist.”
Copyright law: the latest
The government and the House of Lords are currently playing ping pong with The Data (Use and Access) Bill which potentially changes copyright law in favour of the AI industry.
The House of Lords is fighting for an amendment that would allow existing copyright law to be enforced. (And if you’re not convinced that the House of Lords is a Good Thing, read Ian Dunt’s excellent book How Westminster Works . . . and Why It Doesn’t.)
Beeban Kidron, a film director and crossbench peer, is leading the way. She argues in a Guardian article: “Our amendment would allow existing copyright law to be enforced: copyright owners would understand when, where and by whom their work was being stolen to train AI. The logic being that if an AI firm has to disclose evidence of theft, it will not steal in the first place.”
It’s questionable how much politicians actually understand about the situation. Ex-politician and more recently Meta executive Nick Clegg got a lot of stick for claiming that asking artists for permission to use their work would ‘kill’ the AI industry. Cue lots of creatives suggesting that perhaps they’ve got the wrong business model.
PRS, the music licensing organisation, responded: “The idea that respecting copyright would ‘kill’ AI shows a lack of understanding of how the creative industries actually work and thrive. Digital licensing frameworks already exist and function at scale. It is not only possible but essential to build a commercial market that respects copyright and protects human creativity.”
Human intelligence
Designer Una Healy has created a website Hi from a Human, aimed at promoting work that was created without the use of AI. You can download a Mark of Human Intelligence to say that your work was composed, created or written using Human Intelligence.
She says: “As humans we have endless curiosity and creativity borne of that intangible, inimitable and irreplaceable essence that we call the human spirit. This living, breathing part of us drives our creativity, using the mind, heart, body and soul. If you want this core aspect of humanity, of which we should all be proud, to continue to thrive, why not mark it and let the world know?”
