The “Make it fair” campaign logo. On a turquoise background, the words “Make it fair” in block capitals. Most of the writing is black but the letters A and I in “fair” are in white so they read as “AI”.

28 February 2025

Media, misinformation and activism

This month I’ve been reading and thinking a lot about media, how we consume it and how we might need to approach it.

Journalism, social media and our choices

There is an ongoing, and growing, discussion taking place about our relationship with the media we consume. Given the current state of geopolitics it feels a very pertinent and urgent subject.

As an NUJ member, I’m very aware of the challenges for people working in newspapers these days, especially in the regional press. Once-important local papers are now owned by huge multinationals focused on cost cutting and clickbait. Without subeditors and with barely enough reporters to fill the pages, quality goes down, meaning that many places around the country are effectively “news deserts” with no meaningful local coverage.

Add to this the growing mistrust of “mainstream media” among the general public, along with the need for new funding models for serious journalism, and we have a problem

Ian Dunt, whose Substack is essential reading, is as incisive as ever in this piece about the collapse of journalism and the vital need to keep real journalism alive.

In the face of the ever-expanding “disinformation ecosystem”, he argues, those of us who care about quality journalism must be prepared to pay for it – perhaps, he suggests, by cancelling one of our television subscriptions.

And we should ask ourselves the question: “What kinds of publications are equipping you with the kind of information about the world which allows you to accomplish things, as an informed citizen or a campaigner?”

A similar question came up in an article about social media from 404 Media titled You Can’t Post Your Way Out Of Fascism.

This thoughtful piece points out that “viral outrage disseminated on social media … actually reduces the effectiveness of collective action.” – because doomscrolling is “always reacting and never acting”.

I’m as guilty as anyone: back when Twitter was a reasonable place to be, it was my first place of refuge when in need of “it’s not just me” reassurance after something bad had happened.

But the article gives examples of actual activism that, yes, may be coordinated online but is based on real-life networks.

Its conclusion: “Under this status quo, everything becomes a myopic contest of who can best exploit people’s anxieties to command their attention and energy. If we don’t learn how to extract ourselves from this loop, none of the information we gain will manifest as tangible action—and the people in charge prefer it that way.”

“As the internet continues to enshittify, maybe what we really need is to start trusting each other and our own collective sense of what is true and good… We need to collectively decide what kind of world we actually do want, and what we’re willing to do to achieve it.

Thanks to Nick Parker for alerting me to this article.

Meanwhile, an interesting piece in The Journalist magazine discusses the recent Ofcom report “Understanding misinformation” and a spin-off conference on people’s attitudes towards news media – including the need to restore trust in mainstream journalism.

AI again

AI and copyright

I have responded to the government consultation on AI and copyright which, as many have pointed out, seems to be pretty flawed. Several of my responses were the same: “You don’t ‘encourage’ people to comply with the law. You penalise them if they break the law.”

The campaign against the government proposals – effectively removing the “all rights reserved” default that has protected creatives for years – continues to hot up. On the morning of 25th February, the day that the consultation finished, all the major national newspapers had the same front cover – a wrap-round promoting the “Make it fair” campaign.

The Guardian has reported that the government might be considering a “partial climbdown” although the details still sound vague and unconvincing. The Guardian piece says this is due to “lobbying from some of the world’s most famous artists”, which ignores the thousands of non-famous people who have responded to the consultation and all the representative bodies who’ve been running long campaigns.

AI and search

Advice on how to remove AI summaries from your search results has, unexpectedly, gone viral. Just add swearing, they say.

You could, of course, just add “-ai”. But that’s not as much fun.

Copyright again

As the discussion on AI and copyright rages, I was fascinated to find out from Britt Sarony that her great grandfather Napoleon Sarony was the first person to secure copyright for a photograph – his now famous photo of Oscar Wilde, back in 1884.

The cloud

One of the many tech stories in the news this month concerned Apple’s “cloud services”.

But isn’t it about time we stopped saying “the cloud” and started saying “data centres”? That might give us a better sense of what we are really dealing with: something tangible that has a real-world, environmental impact.

This month’s Nice Thing

Back in the days of Twitter, I used to often post something I called #TodaysNiceThing (usually based on art or nature). I’ve recently started doing it on Bluesky.

So here is this month’s Nice Thing: a whole load of human creators making designs that flag up their work as “created with human intelligence”.

Hat tip to Beth Spencer who kicked off the whole idea, and created the logo below.

A hand-drawn image of a hand, drawing. In a circle around it, the words

Contact me