Criticism and context: why we still need professional reviewers

7 Oct 2015 | Journalism

Is being a music writer “tough and important work”? Well, one music writer thinks it is. Tim Sommer, writing in the New York Observer, argues that “Daily newspapers need music writers now more than ever.”

He’s talking about writing for a USA “big city daily” and, while there’s no equivalent in the UK, his arguments also apply to writers on local newspapers here. Having worked as a writer on a regional daily newspaper – I was pop columnist for the Liverpool Echo – I think he makes some good points.

Why is this important, and what’s it got to do with the internet?

The rise of the blogger and the growth of consumer reviews have created a landscape where anyone can write about music, or other art forms. And this has called into question the future of the professional critic, many of whom are no longer valued by the publications that used to employ them.

Even Robert Christgau, one of the earliest professional rock critics, has become a victim. After making a living as a journalist for more than 50 years, he’s found that his employers are no longer prepared to pay for his work.

But it’s not just about people making a living, important though that is. As SF Weekly reporter Matt Saincome says of the Christgau situation: “When it comes to critical analysis and writing, you get what you pay for.”

Anyone can gush about something they like. Anyone can allocate marks out of five. Not everyone can be a critic.

I’ve recently been reading Mark Kermode’s book about film criticism, Hatchet Job, and his view is that what makes you a “proper” critic is being able to sit through the films no-one else wants to watch. Watching all the new releases – good and bad – allows you to write accountable reviews that include “opinion, description, contextualisation and analysis”.

In my days as a music reviewer, I watched a lot of acts that I would not otherwise have seen. Sometimes they were awful, but often I was pleasantly surprised.  And when it came to writing about them, I tried, as Tim Sommer puts it, to: “avoid being swept away by trends, yet remain informed enough to report accurately about them and place them within a workable and realistic context”.

Me and a friend backstage at a gig.

Backstage, and reaching for my notebook.

It’s easy to write about things you like, and there’s room for “fanboy” reviews, but without context – what Tim Sommer calls “knowledge and perspective” – you’re not a critic. This means knowing about history and influences, about movements and trends, and about having benchmarks for what’s new, what’s good and what’s original (and recognising a cover version when you hear one). And when writing for a local paper, it means knowing the local cultural landscape as well as the national/international context. I liked his view that a good local journalist “helps keep alive the cultural tradition of the city where they write”. It’s something I felt proud to be part of.

I don’t do that job any more but I like reading people who do, and who do it well. (My favourite music writer is the Guardian’s Laura Barton, who combines knowledge, passion and wonderfully lyrical writing.)

That is something we need to value, and I hope Mark Kermode is right. He faces up to the doom-mongers by declaring that “unpaid amateurism is ultimately unsustainable”, and concludes from experience that, despite everything, professional criticism is here to stay.


recent posts

Close up of a garden plant - alchemilla mollis.
Now that’s what I call working out loud
Another lockdown first, some new words and the future of content strategy
Doorway to a butcher's shop, with a notice saying "Max 2 customers in shop please."
Zoom fatigue, lockdown houses and a defence of journalism
Two Canada geese standing at the edge of a small lake.
An unusual April: not another post about working from home
Pebble on the ground, painted blue with the message: "To the people who find this, stay safe."
“Stay safe”: a month where communication is more important than ever
A selection of playing cards from the SDG2030 Game.
Saving the world, making content readable and how to upset a copywriter: what I learnt in February
Tech, sustainability and food: what I learnt in January
A tray of "Christmas doughnuts".
Weeknote 25: red vinyl, Brexit and Father Christmas
Screengrab of the Ashmolean Museum website, with an online "Advent calendar". Six windows have been opened and show different winter-themed artworks.
Weeknote 24: Black Friday, Advent and “me too” marketing
Weeknote 23: sustainability, pizza and a cat
Weeknote 22: IT jargon, style sheets and air pollution
A sign on an empty card rack in a shop: "We're getting ready for Christmas. We apologise for any disruption whilst we make these changes."
Weeknote 21: Substances derived from food, and other new words
"Lifeguard Service" poster on beach. Words include: "RNLI Lifeguards and the 'orange' Seafront Advisors operate on this beach during the summer season. Lifeguards on duty when red and yellow flags are flying."
Weeknote 20: Sustainable development, tech in Oxford and why you need subeditors
Wallingford Bunkfest: a festival atmosphere with families, flags and stalls in a park with a blue sky.
Weeknote 19: Being nice is good for business. And scaring people is not.
Didcot power station's cooling towers, looking beautiful in the dawn light.
Weeknote 18: Cold emails, hot weather and a new tech magazine
A shelf of books in a bookshop, with a label reading 'Memoirs' made of Scrabble tiles.
Weeknote 17: Mostly about pictures. And books.
Book cover for 'Because Internet'.
Weeknote 16: Favourite websites, favourite books
Tweet from BBC Weather: picture of weather map showing 39 degrees, with the words 'Morning, if we're going to do it TODAY'S THE DAY! We will of course keep you posted. Lou L.'
Weeknote 15: Heatwaves, podcasts and the benefits of being quiet
A flowerpot overlooking a large lawn with trees and shrubs.
Weeknote 14: History lessons, user-centred design and the state of LinkedIn
A display banner with the words "Be more creative" in a repeat pattern.
Weeknote 13: Be more creative
Weeknote 12: Networking or not
TwitterUK reception
Weeknote 11: A visit to Twitter
Badge on a jacket lapel with the words "Votes for women".
Weeknote 10: How not to be an entrepreneur
Extract from letter from Honda (text in blog)
Weeknote 9: Euphemisms and poems
A computer playing Snap with a human. From an April Fool's Day video by Oxford University.
Weeknote 8: Sleevenotes and subeditors
A stack of books, with the titles Tyger, Tiger, Burning Bright, and In The Forest.
Weeknote 7: Poetry and petitions
Poster with text: "They may not be avoiding you. They may just be: 1. Distracted by a sudden life change. 2. Working hard to make ends meet or to make sense of their situation. 3. Too worn out to socialize. 4. Dealing with personal pain or illness. 5. Tired of having to pretend to be okay around you when they're really doing all they can to survive. Don't make snap judgments. You just never know."
Weeknote 5: How much do you tell your clients?
Heart Unions logo
Weeknote 4: Sharing the love
Two books: Neurotribes by Steve Silberman, and Transciption by Kate Atkinson.
Weeknote 3: Websites and wish lists
Job advert that says "Identifying sales opportunities to introduce complimentary products".
Weeknote 2: Admin and sadmin
A statue of a bull, with a knitted scarf around its neck.
A weeknote about weeknotes
Style guides for the 21st century (part 2): A universal style guide?
Style guides for the 21st century (part 1): What is a style guide anyway?
Lily-of-the-valley flowers in a garden.
Communicating climate change: bank holidays, spring flowers and church conversations
Introductory slide from the meetup: "Content, Seriously".
Content design again
Content design: what is it and how do you do it?
Still from Traidcraft video: "This year, a third of all people want Black Friday to be stopped."
How to disrupt Black Friday, and other comms tips: things I learned in November
Flyers for Optimise Oxford
Optimise Oxford: social media, sell-side and SEO
A newspaper stand with British newspapers, the day before the Brexit referendum.
Five things Brexit can teach you about communication
How to learn from your clients
Content marketing the old fashioned way
How to cope with colleague-generated content
How many apps does it take to change a lightbulb?
Social media and your career (part 3): How to talk to people on Twitter
angel blowing a trumpet
Social media and your career (part 2): Do you look like a professional?
knickerblocker glory
Branding or boring? Social media and your career (part 1)
Twitter dialogue between me and First Great Western
A lesson from the floods: how to use social media for customer service
Social media for charities: anyone can do it
Slide 'Don't forget to pay the freelancer!'
The Content Marketing Show: seeing what sticks
Boats in Beer
When should you relaunch a website (and what does relaunch mean, anyway)?
copy of Plain Words book
Gove v Gowers: rules for writing
Sue Davis and others at the London Content Strategy Meetup
Content strategists: who are these people?
Oxford NUJ Twitter header
Five reasons why journalists should build an online presence
On and off again

subscribe to my blog

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.